Affiliate links: as an Amazon Associate and through other programs, we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. Learn more.
In This Article
What the research shows for each option
Black cohosh
- Dose in studies: a median of 40 mg of extract a day; the most studied product is standardized to the equivalent of 40 mg of root a day (NIH ODS).
- What the research found: a Cochrane review of 16 trials (2,027 women) found no significant difference from placebo in how often hot flashes happened and called the evidence insufficient (Leach and Moore, 2012). An earlier meta-analysis of 7 trials reported a 26% improvement, with large differences between trials (Shams et al., 2010).
- Watch out for: at least 83 reports of liver damage worldwide, although a causal link has not been proven. Stop and see a doctor if you get stomach pain, dark urine or yellow skin, and do not use it in pregnancy (NIH ODS).
Soy isoflavones and S-equol
- Dose in studies: about 54 mg of soy isoflavones a day, or 10 mg of S-equol a day
- What the research found: a meta-analysis of 13 trials found that soy isoflavones cut hot flash frequency by 20.6% more than placebo (Taku et al., 2012). In 160 Japanese women who do not make equol themselves, 10 mg of S-equol a day for 12 weeks cut hot flash frequency by 58.7%, against 34.5% with placebo (Aso et al., 2012). A Cochrane review of phytoestrogens in general was less positive and found no conclusive evidence (Lethaby et al., 2013).
- Watch out for: if you have had breast cancer or another hormone-sensitive condition, ask your doctor before taking soy extracts.
Magnesium: not supported for hot flashes
- What the research found: in 289 women with a history of breast cancer, magnesium oxide (800 or 1,200 mg a day) did no better than placebo for hot flashes and caused more diarrhea (Park et al., 2015).
- If you take magnesium for other reasons: stay at or below 350 mg a day from supplements, the NIH upper limit (NIH ODS).
Sage
- Dose in studies: one tablet of fresh sage leaf a day; there is no established dose in mg.
- What the research found: in an open study without a placebo group, 71 women taking a daily sage tablet reported 50% fewer intensity-rated hot flashes after 4 weeks and 64% fewer after 8 weeks (Bommer et al., 2011). Without a placebo, part of that may be a placebo effect. The NIH says a few small studies suggest a benefit (NCCIH).
- Watch out for: common sage contains thujone, which can be toxic in large amounts or with long use. Studies lasted up to 8 weeks, and it may be unsafe in pregnancy (NCCIH).
How the options compare
Doses are the ones used in the studies above. Effects were modest at best.
| Supplement | Dose in studies | Evidence for hot flashes |
|---|---|---|
| Soy isoflavones | About 54 mg a day | About 21% fewer hot flashes than placebo in a meta-analysis |
| S-equol | 10 mg a day | One 12-week trial in women who do not make equol |
| Black cohosh | 40 mg a day (median) | Mixed; a Cochrane review found no clear effect |
| Sage | 1 fresh-leaf tablet a day | One small study without a placebo |
| Magnesium | Not recommended for hot flashes | No better than placebo in a large trial |
Should you combine them
No trial has tested these supplements together, and combining products for the same symptom does not add evidence. In a 2006 trial, a multi-herb product plus soy foods even left women with worse symptoms than placebo after 12 months (NIH ODS).
If you want to try one, give it 8 to 12 weeks, the length of the trials above, and keep a simple hot flash diary so you can judge whether it helps.
Get our free supplement cheat sheet.
One page: typical doses, timing and upper limits for ten well-studied supplements. No upsell.
🔒 No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. We send 1-2 emails/month max.
How to choose a product
- Soy isoflavones: look for the genistein content on the label. In the meta-analysis, products with more than 18.8 mg of genistein were more than twice as effective as lower-genistein products (Taku et al., 2012).
- S-equol: the positive trials were in women who do not produce equol from soy themselves (Daily et al., 2019).
- Black cohosh: choose a product that names its extract and daily dose; the most studied one is standardized to the equivalent of 40 mg of root a day (NIH ODS).
- Avoid “menopause blends” that hide the dose of each herb behind a proprietary blend.
Side effects, interactions and safety
Black cohosh: most studies lasted 6 months or less, so long-term safety is unknown. Liver damage has been reported, and the American Herbal Products Association advises against it in pregnancy unless a health professional supervises it (NIH ODS).
Sage: may be unsafe in high doses, with long use or in pregnancy because of its thujone content (NCCIH).
Soy extracts: the 12-week S-equol trial reported no serious side effects (Aso et al., 2012). Ask your doctor first if you have had a hormone-sensitive cancer.
Frequently Asked Questions
What works best for hot flashes?
Hormone therapy works better than black cohosh in head-to-head trials (Leach and Moore, 2012). For women who cannot or do not want to use hormones, The Menopause Society recommends cognitive behavioral therapy, clinical hypnosis, certain antidepressants (SSRIs or SNRIs), gabapentin, fezolinetant and oxybutynin, and does not recommend supplements or herbal remedies (The Menopause Society, 2023).
Does black cohosh work?
The results are mixed. A Cochrane review found no significant difference from placebo in hot flash frequency (Leach and Moore, 2012), while an earlier meta-analysis reported a 26% improvement with large differences between trials (Shams et al., 2010).
Is red clover worth trying?
Probably not. In a Cochrane review, a red clover extract did not reduce how often hot flashes happened compared with placebo (Lethaby et al., 2013).
Can magnesium help night sweats?
There is no good evidence. In a trial of 289 women, magnesium oxide did no better than placebo for hot flashes (Park et al., 2015).
How long should I try a supplement?
The trials above lasted 8 to 12 weeks. If you notice no change by then, it is unlikely to help, and black cohosh has not been studied for long-term use.
Bottom Line
Talk to your doctor about hormone therapy or prescription non-hormonal options first: they have the strongest evidence. If you prefer to try a supplement, soy isoflavones or S-equol have the best trial results, and the effects are modest. Black cohosh has mixed results and liver warnings, and magnesium does not help hot flashes. For other symptoms, see our menopause supplement guide.



